Jul 6, 2016

Even as Prakash Javadekar was being elevated to a Cabinet minister, and handed over the department of Human Resource Development, a two-member bench of the High Court in Mumbai was issuing some stern obiters: that schools have become money-spinning rackets, education resembled hospitals, and in some cases, they amounted to extortion.

It was in the context of a school charging Rs 52,000 for stationery and uniform for a 11-year-old Mumbai student and failure to pay, led to a transfer certificate. But the general tone of what the judges said is something the new HRD minister should take seriously. Education in India doesn't have the student at its Centre anymore, but profits are.

It is not a contention with regard to only schools, but across the spectrum of institutions, right up to universities. It will be not incorrect to describe universities as factories, with the VC as the managing director, the heads of departments as heads of verticals, the principals as shop floor supervisors, and the students, who are the products as good as the cheap items smuggled from China.

There could be exceptions, and there could be institutions of academic excellence and eminence such as the IITs and IIMs, but only that. Rest, including in the frighteningly growing private sector in education, sponsor nightly news programmes on TV to garner an image, and some say they are research and innovation driven. But universities are supposed to be just that, and isn’t it tragic that one has to advertise it as its USP?

His predecessor is seen more as a controversy-courting, aggressive minister, who had an agenda — certainly not her own but the promotion of an ideology which the right wing swears by — and as a successor, Javadekar may well do the country a service by making education worth its description, and those who get it, useful. Towards that end, he needs to hunker down in his office, think, and diligently work.

Avoiding the areas that Smrti Irani waded into, Javadekar, a former journalist who is also a good generalist, can reinvent the system and truly skill the country. PTI

For starters, Javadekar may as well sit with S Ramadorai, former head of TCS who had said that there were a dearth of engineers, but there certainly is a dearth of employable engineers. He belonged to a sector that has been growing — IT. He may as well spend time with Infosys founder Narayana Murthy, who pointed out five years back that even IITs were getting poor quality entrants.

If Infosys has to retrain those hires, because the "the quality of education that they have received is not what we would like them to have. Therefore, we have to train them to make them relevant to the firm." This is a social and economic burden on a sector that does not seek sops from the government to innovate and grow. And, as in Maharashtra, a third of engineering seats are going to be vacant.

It is as if the country has lost its way in this sphere, and just keeps squeezing the half-filled balloon in the name of reforms and corrections, and with regard to even the initial schooling, has allowed the private sector to bloom. This has led to an adverse situation where those who can pay are better-off in the gains they make at a price, than the ones who have to settle for the neighbouring government school where teachers get paid more, per the pay commission, but deliver less.

Javadekar’s own state, Maharashtra, where his own party is at the helm, has seen teachers employed in private but unaided schools for a pittance and make-do with second jobs — even driving auto rickshaws or taking to working on farms, not exactly a profile that adds the gravitas a teacher has to bring to his/her work, apart from, of course, skill. And despite such private, though poor investment, and the government’s own, where are we?

The government needs to start a skill programme because there are others too who had to escape education not only due to disinclination for it but also due to the inability to attend even a free school. The out-of-pocket expenses must have been daunting enough for their parents to keep them out of school long enough to have learnt something useful. But there are surveys showing that a Class 7 student cannot read or write or do sums he or she should have learnt to do in Class 3.

This does appear as an alarmist scenario but it is alarming for our reforms — such as they are, and if they are of no
significant dimension — that have not taken us anywhere. Access to university education is of no purpose if those who get there are poor — like Narayana Murthy’s lament cited earlier — in standards of basic education. It is like the neo-literates — oh yes, when did you last hear of a literacy campaign? — who, just by being a whisker away from a thumb impression think they have done some schooling.

What Javadekar should strive for, and secure rapidly, are these: One, make syllabus the same across the country breaking down the differences between the IBs, ICSC, CBSC, SSC, the last distinct to each state, regulate school fees and eliminate extortion — once it was called capitation fee — and ensure a decent level of proficiency among teachers. In his own state, not even five percent of those with degrees or diplomas in education manage to pass eligibility tests, and they remain teachers.

Once that is done, crack the whip enough to make sure that a churan (digestive) seller does not have the gumption to set up a university as in Aligarh, or a politician does not become a chancellor of a private university because he set it up. Avoiding the areas that Smrti Irani waded into, Javadekar, a former journalist who is also a good generalist, can reinvent the system and truly skill the country. This is tough because vested interests are many, with their toes visible. That would be human resource development. Otherwise, it's a pure swank.

Ask the common man, he would agree this should be the agenda.


NB: News shared form other public portal for general awareness.


Share with social media:

User's Comments:

Sigourney mcgowan

New essential component of the institute is vaguely studied and ensured for the operation for the citizens. The manner of the styles and essayswriting reviews are held for the captivity of the goals or the citizens. The right use is find for the pictures and captions for the width of the goals for the humans for the society.

Oct. 11, 2019, 1:26 p.m. Reply
Cynthia ashley

I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative Gentlemen Tracksuit

March 6, 2021, 5:31 p.m. Reply
123 hp com setup

Alle Dienste für den 123 HP Drucker werden bestmöglich bereitgestellt 123 hp com setup / Wenn Sie den 123-PS-Drucker kürzlich haben und Hilfe beim schnellen Einrichten finden, hp drucker installieren / größtes Engagement und Aufrichtigkeit für unsere Arbeit, alle Druckerservices für Benutzer auf außergewöhnliche Weise bereitzustellen 123 hp com / Der Grund, warum Sie unsere 123 PS bevorzugen sollten,123 hp com envy / Alle Dienste für den 123 HP Drucker werden bestmöglich bereitgestellt. 123hpcom bietet allen Benutzern mit größter Sorgfalt die besten druckerbasierten Dienste.123 hp com Officejet / In kürzester Zeit werden Sie feststellen, dass Ihr Drucker eingerichtet wurde und mit extremer Geschwindigkeit arbeitet, die mit keinem anderen Dienst als mit unseren HP Printer Diensten möglich ist.123 hp Ojpro / Wir bieten Ihnen hier nicht nur die Einrichtung und Installation des Druckers 123 hp com Laserjet / Unser Team unterstützt nicht nur die Konfiguration des HP Druckers 123 hp com LJPro / Alle technischen und nichttechnischen Probleme können von unserem Expertenteam in Ihrem 123-PS-Drucker hp envy installieren / Erreichen Sie unsere 123-PS-Dienste unter der Kontaktnummer, um die Konfiguration zu vereinfachen! hp Officejet installieren / Um Hardwareprobleme schnell zu beheben, rufen Sie uns an. 123 hp com Ojpro / Unabhängig davon, welches HP Druckermodell Sie haben, bietet es Ihnen den besten Servicehp Laserjet installieren / Ermöglicht das direkte Drucken von einem iOS-Gerät ohne Anwendung oder Software.hp LJPro installieren / Drucken Sie direkt von einem drahtlosen Gerät, ohne dass eine Internetverbindung erforderlich treiber / Drucken Sie mit der CloudPrint-Funktion aus dem Chromebook und auch direkt aus Google Chrome.123 hp com hp smart software / 123 HP com envy 6000 / 123 HP com envy 5030 / 123 hp com envy 6032 / 123 hp com envy pro series 6430 / 123 hp com envy 6030 / 123 hp com deskjet 2721 / 123 hp com deskjet 2700 series / 123 hp com deskjet plus 4100 / 123 hp com deskjet 2720 / 123 HP com officeJet 3830 all-in-One series / 123 HP com officeJet 6950 All-in-One series.

June 19, 2021, 6:10 p.m. Reply - Microsoft Office Setup 365 mit Schlüssel / Microsoft Office ist seit vielen Jahren unser Begleiter, seit der Geschäftsbereich floriert office setup / Wählen Sie nun das Land und die Sprache Ihrer Region office installieren.

June 19, 2021, 6:10 p.m. Reply
Meticore supplement

The world's first, 100% common arrangement intended to traget low center internal heat level meticore supplement Meticore is the lone item on the planet with a ptoprietary mix of 6 of the greatest quality supplements what is best supplement for weight loss

June 19, 2021, 6:10 p.m. Reply

Here I find them a very interesting and informative website. Escorts in Gurgaon

July 23, 2021, 4:15 p.m. Reply

I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting Gurgaon Call Girls

July 24, 2021, 12:19 p.m. Reply
Cynthia ashley

Wow amazing Thread. One thing i would like to say you that keep doing good work like this. Thank you so much for sharing this with us, Keep uploading more Suicide Squad 2 Jackets

July 24, 2021, 5:48 p.m.
Sheeba saifi

I would like to say that this blog really convinced me to do it! Thanks, very good post. Call Girl Whatsapp Group in Gurgaon | Call Girlfriend Relationship in Gurgaon | Call Girls for friendship | Online Booking Call Girl | Gurgaon Divorced Females | Housewife Gurgaon Escorts | Russian Escorts |

Dec. 23, 2021, 1:17 p.m. Reply
Sheeba saifi

Hi! this is nice article you shared with great information. Thanks for giving such a wonderful informative information. Cheap Gurgaon Escorts | Air Hostess Escorts in Gurgaon | Body Massage in Gurgaon Home Service Price | GFE Escorts Service in Gurgaon | Gurgaon Model Escorts | Independent Escorts in Gurgaon | Book Escorts Online in Gurgaon |

Dec. 23, 2021, 1:18 p.m. Reply

Air Max 97 Reviews AIR MAX 97 BLOG SB Duck Low Reviews SB DUCK LOW BLOG SB Duck High reviews SB Duck High blog Blazer Reviews BLAZER BLOG Air Force 1 reviews Air Force 1 blog Air Max 1 reviews Air Max 1 blog Nike kobe reviews M2K TEKNO REVIEWS M2K TEKNO blog AIR MAX 90REVIEWS airmax90blog air Max 95reviews air Max 95blog AIR MAX 270 Yes, the Air Max 97 is indeed celebrating its 25th Anniversary, which means the brand is willing to unleash a number of stylish that hit that nostalgic mark.

April 15, 2022, 12:45 p.m. Reply

Active News and Notices